Counterfeit Bullion and the Science of Verification
Why every modern dealer’s bench looks the way it does, and what the verification science can and cannot do.
In 2012, a gold dealer in Manhattan’s diamond district bought what appeared to be a sealed 10-ounce PAMP Suisse gold bar. The assay card was perfect. The serial number checked out. A surface X-ray reading registered as gold. But something about the weight felt fractionally wrong. He drilled into it. Inside, a tungsten core sheathed in a thin layer of gold.
The bar had passed every casual test. It took deliberate destruction to expose it.
That case, and several like it, redrew the map of bullion verification. It also explains why every modern dealer’s toolkit looks the way it does — and why the question “how do I spot a fake?” turns out to have both a precise answer and an honest one.
Why tungsten changed everything
For most of the history of precious metals, counterfeiting was a problem of density. Lead at 11.34 grams per cubic centimetre and copper at 8.96 sit nowhere near gold at 19.32, so a counterfeit bar was exposed by a basic balance. Silver fakes faced the same arithmetic: silver at 10.49 g/cm³ is markedly heavier than the brass and pewter alloys typically used to imitate it.
Tungsten broke that pattern. At 19.25 g/cm³, its density sits within 0.4% of gold’s. It costs roughly one fifteen-hundredth of gold by weight. It withstands the heat of casting. It can be machined to precise dimensions. For a workshop willing to put in the engineering, it makes near-undetectable gold counterfeits possible.
What tungsten cannot replicate is gold’s softness. Gold scores 2.5 to 3 on the Mohs hardness scale; tungsten scores 7.5. Nor can tungsten replicate gold’s electrical conductivity, acoustic profile, or behaviour under ultrasonic interrogation. These differences are the basis of every modern detection method that actually works.
A short history of fake metal
Counterfeiting precious metals is older than coinage itself. Roman emperors progressively debased the silver denarius from the first century onward, and counterfeit Spanish reales circulated through colonial America. In the 1980s, fake Krugerrands became a regular fixture of Hong Kong markets — typically copper cores plated in gold.
What changed in recent decades is sophistication and scale. Dedicated workshops, primarily in parts of Asia, now produce convincing replicas of bars and coins from PAMP, the Perth Mint, the Royal Canadian Mint, Heraeus and Argor-Heraeus, complete with serial numbers, holograms and forged certificates of authenticity. The Manhattan case was not isolated; tungsten-cored bars have surfaced periodically at refineries, dealers and private vaults across Europe and North America.
In Australia, counterfeit Perth Mint and PAMP products appear regularly on second-hand resale platforms. They are typically silver-plated lead, brass kangaroos finished to mimic gold, or — at the more sophisticated end — tungsten or silver-cored gold-plated bars packaged in convincing assay cards.
The low-tech defences
The first line of verification is the human eye. Counterfeiters routinely cut corners on edge detail, micro-engraving and field texture that real mints produce to exact tolerances. The reeded edges on Sovereigns, Britannias, Eagles and Kangaroos are precisely consistent; counterfeit edges are frequently uneven or soft. The Perth Mint introduced a micro-laser engraved security feature inside the first “A” of “AUSTRALIA” on its bullion Kangaroo series — visible only under magnification — and similar features now appear across most major sovereign coins.
Dimensions follow. Every legitimate bullion product has tightly specified dimensions and weight. A 1oz gold Kangaroo measures 32.6 mm in diameter and 2.65 mm in thickness, weighing exactly 31.107 grams. Fakes are routinely off by a fraction of a millimetre — most often thicker, because a lower-density metal has been padded out to hit the correct weight. Digital calipers and a 0.01-gram precision scale expose most of these in seconds.
A neodymium magnet exposes a different category of fake. Gold and silver are both diamagnetic — neither attracts. A magnet sliding down a real silver bar slows visibly under Lenz’s law, the eddy currents braking the magnet as it passes. A magnet sticking to a “silver” coin tells you everything in two seconds. The limitation: a tungsten-cored gold fake will not stick either, so the magnet test is necessary but not sufficient.
The ping test is the simplest and most evocative. Strike a real silver coin with a fingernail or another coin and it produces a distinctive sustained ring — almost a chime — lasting several seconds. A counterfeit thuds. Smartphone apps now analyse the frequency signature against a reference database. The test is less useful for gold, which has a duller acoustic profile, and not useful for bars, so we cannot rely on this test with confidence.
Finally, Archimedes. Specific gravity testing — weighing the item dry, weighing it suspended in water, computing density from the difference — exposes nearly every counterfeit metal except tungsten. For gold, that one exception is exactly the one that matters.
The high-tech defences
This is where the modern dealer’s bench gets interesting.
The Sigma Metalytics Precious Metal Verifier has become the standard handheld device in the bullion trade. It transmits low-frequency electromagnetic waves through the metal and measures the resistivity that bounces back. Every metal has a distinct conductivity signature, and the Sigma’s waves penetrate several millimetres into the sample — well past any surface plating. A tungsten-cored gold bar that has passed every other test fails the Sigma in under a second, because tungsten’s conductivity is less than half of gold’s.
Ultrasonic testing operates on the same principle in a different medium. Sound waves at frequencies above human hearing travel through metal at speeds determined by the medium. Gold’s velocity of sound is around 3,240 metres per second; tungsten’s is 5,180. An ultrasonic tester reading the echo pattern across a bar’s thickness can detect not just surface impurities but internal voids and cores. A tungsten-cored gold bar produces a distinctive multi-bounce echo signature impossible to fake.
X-ray fluorescence — typically a Thermo Scientific Niton XL3t or comparable handheld analyser — fires X-rays into the metal and reads the secondary radiation emitted by each element. The reading reports exactly what is in the surface layer. XRF is superb for verifying surface composition, with one critical limitation: it penetrates only about 0.05 millimetres. A gold-plated tungsten bar reads as gold on XRF every time. This is why some dealers use XRF and Sigma together — XRF confirms the surface, Sigma confirms the core.
Destructive assay is the final answer. Drill the bar, send a sample for fire assay. Reliable, definitive, irreversible.
What the mints have done
Modern mints have embedded security features into their products specifically to make counterfeit production economically irrational. PAMP Suisse Lady Fortuna bars are sold in tamper-evident CertiPAMP packaging linked to the Veriscan authentication system, which captures the bar’s microscopic surface topography as a unique digital fingerprint. The Royal Canadian Mint laser-engraves a textured maple-leaf privy mark, with the year micro-engraved inside it, on its Maple Leaf coins as part of the BullionDNA program. The Royal Australian Mint embeds micro-stamping on higher-value issues.
The logic is consistent across the industry: a counterfeiter can replicate gross design, but reproducing micro-features requires capital expenditure that erodes the margin that made the counterfeit profitable in the first place.
The honest limits
No single test is foolproof. Every method has a counter-method, and counterfeiters using modern CNC equipment and machine-learning-assisted die replication continue to close gaps. The strongest individual defence is layered: visual, dimensional, magnetic, Sigma, XRF, in combination.
The verification science exists because counterfeiters keep getting better, and every layer of defence is eventually probed by an adversary willing to spend on the next one. The bullion industry’s answer has not been to find a single unbeatable test — none exists — but to use a combination to identify fakes before they purchase them.
By Guardian Gold Australia
Guardian Gold Australia is a leading bullion trading company and is part of Australia’s largest private vaulting group- Guardian Vaults.
To follow our market commentary and more, create a free trading account online HERE.
Follow Us On Socials
Disclaimers: Guardian Gold, Registered Office, Scottish House, 100 William Street, Melbourne, Victoria, 3000. ACN 138618176 (“Guardian Vaults” & “Guardian Gold”) All rights reserved. Any reproduction, copying, or redistribution, in whole or in part, is prohibited without written permission from the publisher and/or the author. Information contained herein is believed to be reliable, but its accuracy cannot be guaranteed. It is not designed to meet your personal situation.
Guardian Gold, its officers, agents, representatives and employees do not hold an Australian Financial Services License (AFSL), are not an authorised representative of an AFSL and otherwise are not qualified to provide you with advice of any kind in relation to financial products. If you require advice about a financial product, you should contact a properly licensed or authorised financial advisor.
The information is indicative and general in nature only and is prepared for information purposes only and does not purport to contain all matters relevant to any particular investment. Subject to any terms implied by law and which cannot be excluded, Guardian Gold, shall not be liable for any errors, omissions, defects or misrepresentations (including by reasons of negligence, negligent misstatement or otherwise) or for any loss or damage (direct or indirect) suffered by persons who use or rely on such information.
The opinions expressed herein are those of the publisher and/or the author and may not be representative of the opinions of Guardian Gold, its officers, agents, representatives and employees. Such information does not take into account the particular circumstances, investment objectives and needs for investment of any person, or purport to be comprehensive or constitute investment or financial product advice and should not be relied upon as such.
Past performance is not indicative of future results. Due to various factors, including changing market conditions and/or laws the content may no longer be reflective of current opinions or positions. You should seek professional advice before you decide to invest or consider any action based on the information provided. If you do not agree with any of the above disclaimers, you should immediately cease viewing or making use of any of the information provided.

A short history of fake metal
What the mints have done

